Showing posts with label west virginia university. Show all posts
Showing posts with label west virginia university. Show all posts

Friday, April 3, 2009

Cancer Center Contributes To War On Disease

The Mary Babb Randolph Cancer Center at West Virginia University is two decades old.  It seems as though the facility has been around for a much longer time.

We have learned a great deal about cancer in the past thirty years.  So much so, that the timeline of the historical record of mankind’s suffering from this disease has been drastically skewed.  In 1980, actor Steve McQueen traveled to Mexico where he took laetrile treatments to try and cure his mesothelioma.  Just last week, cancer survivor Lance Armstrong was back in the hospital, this time for a broken collarbone suffered while riding his bicycle.

Steve McQueen, the daredevil biker who did everything but sing “Edelweiss” as he toured the German countryside when filming “The Great Escape”, was hopelessly condemned by cancer.  Lance Armstrong, on the other hand, not only survived testicular cancer but went on to become France’s most famous two-wheeling tourist.  He didn’t sing “Edelweiss” either, but he did date Sheryl Crowe for awhile.

We have gone from cancer being a certain death sentence to being “doable” in a moment of time. 

The first designed chemotherapy drug, methotrexate, appeared exactly sixty years ago.  The drug proved effective against childhood leukemia, but medical science as a whole was skeptical that childhood leukemia was even curable.

It’s not that humans haven’t known about cancer for a long time.  The Greeks and Romans used their respective words for “crab” to also define cancer.  Cancerous tumors resemble the appearance of a crab.

The Greek physician Hippocrates described cancer about 400 B. C.  From this point, you can fast-forward to the start of the twentieth century because not much happened to expand man’s knowledge of cancer during that epoch.  The year 1902 stands out, however, with Madame Curie’s discovery of radium and Thomas Edison’s growing manufacture of X-ray machines.  It wasn’t long after until people learned about radiation and its consequences from overexposure.

Many of you remember wearing a lead apron while your dentist hid in a concrete bunker and pushed a button to X-ray your teeth.  The apron protected your torso (and little else) from inadvertent overexposure.  Unless you wore a tin foil hat, you can probably assume that some of your brain cells were fried.  Today, however, radiation oncologists can aim pinpoint beams of radiation at the actual tumor site.

The gains that we have made in curing cancer during the last thirty years are due in large part to a greatly expanded National Cancer Institute and the advent of regional cancer centers such as MBRCC.  As patients, we tend to focus on individual cancer treatment.  While the cancer center provides state-of-the-art patient treatment, its role goes far beyond that.

The research laboratories at MBRCC and the Health Science Center have had notable success in making critical discoveries.  For example, Dr. Laura Gibson’s team discovered that cancer cells can hide in the bone marrow where they cannot be reached by chemotherapy drugs.  And Dr. Wei-Shau Hu discovered that two retroviruses can infect the same cell and swap DNA.

If imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, then kudos to Dr. Kimberly Horn and Dr. Geri Dino of WVU’s Health Science Center.  In partnership with MBRCC, Drs. Horn and Dino developed the “Not On Tobacco” program which has been the model for teenage tobacco cessation programs across the nation.  The Centers for Disease Control recently launched a website to promote the N-O-T program.

As part of its outreach mission, the MBRCC will be sending Bonnie’s Bus, a mobile mammogram unit, around the state.  Women in rural areas will soon find much easier access to digital mammography.

The MBRCC opened its Blood and Marrow Transplantation program in 1992 and it remains the only accredited such program in West Virginia.

The MBRCC is a matrix cancer center and was designed to take advantage of not only the HSC’s elements but the WVU campus as a whole.  It has been a success.  This month, the MBRCC will double in size when it dedicates its expanded facility. 

I do hope, however, that cancer is cured before the MBRCC celebrates forty years.

There is a good benchmark to show how far we have come in treating cancer.  One of the drugs that cured Lance Armstrong was discovered in 1845 and named Peyrone’s salt after its discoverer.  Now called cisplatin, its anticancer properties were discovered quite by accident in 1970.  Cisplatin began clinical trials in 1978, just in time to save Lance Armstrong.

Friday, June 20, 2008

Boards Must Have Balance, Integrity

Because of the ongoing turmoil at West Virginia University, the subject of appointing directors to the university's governing board has been a much-discussed topic. Let's take a moment to consider the right people for the job.

When selecting a board member-- and this applies to every organization -- the candidate must have a common interest or commonality of purpose with regard to the institution. If not, why bother?

While this requirement seems simple enough, it never fails that two undesirable types of people pass the commonality test--the proverbial "yes" man and the parasite. Even the most diligent screening process cannot always weed out these people.

Sitting on a board can have an intoxicating influence on even the most well-intentioned people. Directors find that the title of board member does afford them status in their communities, and at some point they might become "yes" men or women so as not to jeopardize losing their directorships. No director that I am aware of was ever fired for toadying.

Other well-intentioned people have compromised their fiduciary duty by doing business with the very institution they are appointed to oversee. Most often, these business arrangements begin as symbiotic relationships with all parties benefiting. When greed sets in, the relationship turns parasitic.

The faculty has expressed that the governing board should have more faculty representatives. This sounds wonderful in theory. But the reality of the campus is that professors rarely know what goes on outside of the buildings they teach in.

Professors also specialize in their field of learning. So who do you pick? The botanist who studies aphid damage? The physicist who looks for dark matter? The historian who debates the cause of the Civil War? Or do we consider the education professor who knows everything about running a classroom but precious little about running a school? Would a professor of proctology even stand a chance?

For the faculty's sake, they should speak collectively through their elected senate rather than through one or more board members. And the faculty senate should have stronger powers, especially so with regard to the presidential selection process. If a presidential candidate can't win the hearts of the faculty senate during his or her interview, then the candidate has no business applying for the job.

There are probably 100 million people on this planet who know who Pat White and Kevin Pittsnogle are. Ten times that many know who Jerry West is. In terms of dollars and cents, WVU's athletic program is not a huge budget item. But in terms of publicity, athletics brings WVU its most attention.

Candidates for the Board of Governors need to be serious about athletics -- and just as serious about demanding a scandal-free athletic program. The football stadium may be named in honor of Milan Puskar, but it will always be remembered as the house that Don Nehlen built. Coach Nehlen was a winner, but let us not forget that he was respected for his integrity from coast to coast.

The Health Science Center is an important part of WVU, and the board needs a few members who are up to speed on modern medicine. While drug company representatives don't get much respect, I will tell you for a fact that they know everything that goes on in the medical community.

I am not recommending a drug pusher for the board. So don't choke.

I point this out, however, because WVU needs to consider people in the medical field who get around and also are knowledgeable of the financial side of the medical business. This is definitely the area where WVU has to think outside the box for recruiting board members.

When Netscape developed JavaScript in 1995, I remarked that java scripts had been around for years. When questioned about my observation, I quipped that boards of directors were in the habit of using the chairman's report as coffee cup coasters to protect their mahogany conference tables.

Bad jokes aside, a board member must be involved and not consider the board meeting a coffee klatch.

A board member's responsibility can be compared somewhat to that of a juror's. When the door is closed, people trust them to make the right decision. Sometimes, those decisions are incredibly unpopular, while at other times they are routine. But all individual decisions made on behalf of a community test a person's resolve, conscience and ethics.

From personal experience, I have seen the damage that self-serving directors can do. I have also seen the good work that responsible directors can do. The final test for selecting a board member is this simple: Picking from the former guarantees a train wreck, while picking from the latter guarantees success.

Friday, May 30, 2008

It Was A Dark And Stormy EMBA Degree

I read the Report of the Special Investigative Panel For Review Of Executive MBA Program Records (at West Virginia University) issued on April 21, 2008. At the outset, I did not believe that five college professors could write with such clarity and brevity. And yet, these five academics did an admirable job in explaining their findings in crystal-clear fashion using as few words as possible.

Therefore, I have been at a loss to understand how there could be any debate about what transpired in awarding Ms. Heather Bresch an Executive MBA degree. The panel concluded that the academic and financial records of West Virginia University were reasonably accurate, that Ms. Bresch received special treatment not afforded any other degree candidate and that her degree was manufactured in the shabbiest way possible -- by overt fraud committed at the highest levels of the university.

The panel could not have made these charges clearer. However, in West Virginia, not all people are fluent in translating the English language into our local dialect.

"The Elements of Style" by Strunk and White is (and has been for decades) the most popular writing primer. The authors are famous for their advocacy of using the active voice when writing. They further recommend that writers avoid using the passive voice.

Unlike Mssrs. Strunk and White, West Virginians tend to speak and write in the passive voice, which derives from their fondness for passivity. The term "miner's mentality" describes the passive attitude of most West Virginians. For my purposes, let's skip the reference to miners and call this behavior the passivity-passive voice complex.

Innumerable people have either said or written, "Mistakes were made" when describing the manner in which university officials manufactured Ms. Bresch's degree. I wondered how they could have read the panel's report and then resort to the passive voice to describe people pulling grades out of thin air.

So I went back to the report and re-read it. On page 12, the panel states, "But again, the grade (--) that was entered in that course (--) was simply pulled from thin air." Well, there you have it -- the passive voice.

In matters relating to science and scholarship, it is customary to use the passive voice in certain situations. For example, it is better to write, "Experiments were conducted" than to write a lengthy preface explaining who conducted the experiments. If it is necessary to name each scientist conducting the experiment, then that information is consigned to a footnote.

The investigative panel's charge did not require the panel to return an indictment against the person or persons who altered Ms. Bresch's transcript. Thus, when the panel wrote, "But again, the grade ... that was entered ... was simply pulled from thin air" they purposely used the passive voice to avoid naming names and going beyond their charge.

Though the circumstance demanded that the panel speak to the alteration of grades in the passive voice, that does not mean that certain people weren't actively doing the pulling. If we allow ourselves to slough this dreadful affair off with words like "Mistakes were made" then we should just assume that the university's computer system is a deus ex machina over which there is no control. And that assumption would be consistent with the passivity-passive voice complex.

West Virginians need to realize that the rest of the world speaks with the active voice and, further, that the rest of the world does not translate the passive voice as necessitating passivity. The rest of the world is dumbstruck that a university would manufacture a degree. But West Virginians have allowed their special interpretation of a few words to cloud their own judgment.

The investigative panel members should be commended for their report. Had the provost appointed five typical West Virginians to the panel, then be assured that their report would consist of three tried-and-true words that you'll hear spoken only in the Mountain State: "You'll have that."

The university's faculty has every right to be incensed about the manufacture of a degree. That said, every single faculty member should have demanded a forum to cast his or her vote in the matters addressed on May 14. As it turned out, less than half bothered to vote.

No amount of protest can ever restore the faculty's virginity. But in this case, Shakespeare might say, "Methinks the Lady doth not protest enough!"

WVU would quickly expel a student caught cheating. The same punishment must apply to everyone involved in this pathetic scandal.

Friday, March 2, 2007

Winning Strategy: West Virginia University Proves Pay Matters

Comparison of Gross Wages:

WVU Football/Men’s Basketball Coaches to WVU College of Business and Economics Ph.D. Professors; Rounded to nearest $1,000

Head Football Coach:         $1,233,000
Asst. Head F/B Coach:            210,000
Asst. Football Coaches (9);   1,334,000  (Aggregate)
Asst. Football Coaches (9);      148,000  (Average)
   
Dean, College of B&E:         $  202,000
Coll. Of B&E; Ph.D. (54)          108,000  (Average)

Head Basketball Coach         $ 849,000
Asst. B/B Coaches (3);            110,000  (Average)
   
Aggregate: FB & BB Coaches (14):     $3,747,000
Aggregate: Coll. Of B&E; PhD (54)      $5,831,000

Sources: WV State Auditor, WVU College of Business & Economics, WVU Athletic Department (via respective websites) 

----------------------------------------------------------
While in the grips of cabin fever last month, I had time to memorize all 1,223 pages of state employees’ wages.

With knowledge comes duty. So I compared West Virginia University coaches’ wages to those of WVU’s College of Business and Economics (CB&E) professors.

For comparison purposes, I limited my study of the CB&E professors to the Ph.D.s listed at www.be.wvu.edu. The football and men’s basketball assistant coaches are those listed in the 2006 coaching guides at www.msnsportsnet.com.

By now, everyone knows how much Rich Rodriguez and John Beilein earned in 2006. What I found more interesting is the payroll of their assistant coaches.

Dean Stephen Sears holds the CB&E’s top-paid position. But Dean Sears made about $8,000 less than Assistant Head Football Coach Rick Trickett. Overall, the average assistant football coach earned 37 percent more than the average Ph.D. professor. The average Ph.D. professor also earned less than the average assistant men’s basketball coach.

The payroll for 14 coaches is almost two-thirds (64 percent) of that for the CB&E’s 54 Ph.D. professors.

Coaching salaries have always been defended by the argument that football and men’s basketball are revenue sports that bring home the bacon. Left unsaid in that argument is the fact that college sports enjoy two substantial subsidies.

College sports are subsidized by tax-exempt donations to the athletic program. Ostensibly, this tax-exempt status was granted in an era when athletic scholarships were the major expense of the department. Now that Division I coaching salaries have mushroomed, Congress has asked the NCAA to justify the tax-exempt status for donations that effectively make high salaries possible.

A second subsidy is the uncompensated labor of scholarship athletes. These youngsters are indentured servants who risk permanent injury when plying their trade. While the athletic department makes money from ticket sales and television contracts, the department’s financial obligation to scholarship athletes consists mainly of room and board and an opportunity for an education.

In making fair comparisons, we need to recognize that the CB&E is also generously subsidized. If Pell grants, PROMISE scholarships, student loan subsidies and transfers from the WVU Foundation and state government stopped tomorrow, the school would easily lose more than half of it students; the professorial ranks would shrink accordingly. As well, the competition for an open professorship would drive salaries down.

In other words, without all of these subsidies, WVU’s campus would look much like it did in the 1950s. Come to think about it, that was WVU’s Golden Age. The rifle team, Sam Huff, Jerry West, three Rhodes Scholars, and a new medical center represented WVU well.

I have no clue as to what the ideal Ph.D. salary should be. Nor do I have access to the national norms for Ph.D. salaries. But my instincts tell me that when the head football coach makes more in one month than half of the CB&E professors make in one year, then Ph.D. pay scales are far too low-not the other way around.

When the football or basketball program goes awry, the old coach is unceremoniously dumped and a new coach is hired to turn the program around in three to four years. If the university’s academic standing falters, then recovery is much more complicated.

A good example of this dilemma is the College of Law’s slide to fourth-tier status in the U.S. News and World Report survey. Rather than read the scoreboard, the faculty remains in denial; they blame the magazine’s survey criteria and beg the need for remodeled classrooms.

At least coaches understand that life is a game, that the game has rules, and that competition is their friend.

In this world, you pretty much get what you pay for. WVU’s success in all of its athletic programs has happened because financial commitments have been made. If the university is to project its academic reputation in the same fashion, then financial commitments for academic salaries must be forthcoming as well.

The law school’s decline may very well be the canary in the coal mine in this regard.

Monday, February 26, 2007

Opinion Writing Considerations

This outline was presented to the Editorial Writing class at the Perley I. Reed School of Journalism, West Virginia University, Feb, 26, 2007.

"Some things, as Orwell wrote, are true even if The Daily Telegraph says they are true."  
    Christopher Hitchens ("A Man with a Score to Settle", London Sunday Times, Jan. 21, 2007)


OVERVIEW

George Orwell was a prolific writer and excellent essayist.  His comments on style are to the point and his advice would be agreed with by other great writers.

STYLE:

Excerpts from "Politics and the English Language," 1946.  Orwell presents five passages by five writers and criticizes them as follows:

"These five passages have not been picked out because they are especially bad -- I could have quoted far worse if I had chosen -- but because they illustrate various of the mental vices from which we now suffer. They are a little below the average, but are fairly representative examples. I number them so that I can refer back to them when necessary:

1. I am not, indeed, sure whether it is not true to say that the Milton who once seemed not unlike a seventeenth-century Shelley had not become, out of an experience ever more bitter in each year, more alien [sic] to the founder of that Jesuit sect which nothing could induce him to tolerate. -- Professor Harold Laski, Essay in Freedom of Expression

2. Above all, we cannot play ducks and drakes with a native battery of idioms which prescribes egregious collocations of vocables as the Basic put up with for tolerate, or put at a loss for bewilder. -- Professor Lancelot Hogben, Interglossa

3. On the one side we have the free personality: by definition it is not neurotic, for it has neither conflict nor dream. Its desires, such as they are, are transparent, for they are just what institutional approval keeps in the forefront of consciousness; another institutional pattern would alter their number and intensity; there is little in them that is natural, irreducible, or culturally dangerous. But on the other side, the social bond itself is nothing but the mutual reflection of these self-secure integrities. Recall the definition of love. Is not this the very picture of a small academic? Where is there a place in this hall of mirrors for either personality or fraternity? -- Essay on psychology in Politics (New York)

4. All the "best people" from the gentlemen's clubs, and all the frantic fascist captains, united in common hatred of Socialism and bestial horror at the rising tide of the mass revolutionary movement, have turned to acts of provocation, to foul incendiarism, to medieval legends of poisoned wells, to legalize their own destruction of proletarian organizations, and rouse the agitated petty-bourgeoise to chauvinistic fervor on behalf of the fight against the revolutionary way out of the crisis. -- Communist pamphlet

5. If a new spirit is to be infused into this old country, there is one thorny and contentious reform which must be tackled, and that is the humanization and galvanization of the B.B.C. Timidity here will bespeak canker and atrophy of the soul. The heart of Britain may be sound and of strong beat, for instance, but the British lion's roar at present is like that of Bottom in Shakespeare's Midsummer Night's Dream -- as gentle as any sucking dove. A virile new Britain cannot continue indefinitely to be traduced in the eyes or rather ears, of the world by the effete languors of Langham Place, brazenly masquerading as "standard English." When the Voice of Britain is heard at nine o'clock, better far and infinitely less ludicrous to hear aitches honestly dropped than the present priggish, inflated, inhibited, school-ma'amish arch braying of blameless bashful mewing maidens! -- Letter in Tribune

"Each of these passages has faults of its own, but, quite apart from avoidable ugliness, two qualities are common to all of them. The first is staleness of imagery; the other is lack of precision."

Basic rules of style

"… one can often be in doubt about the effect of a word or a phrase, and one needs rules that one can rely on when instinct fails. I think the following rules will cover most cases:

(i) Never use a metaphor, simile, or other figure of speech which you are used to seeing in print.
(ii) Never use a long word where a short one will do.
(iii) If it is possible to cut a word out, always cut it out.
(iv) Never use the passive where you can use the active.
(v) Never use a foreign phrase, a scientific word, or a jargon word if you can think of an everyday English equivalent.
(vi) Break any of these rules sooner than say anything outright barbarous.

"These rules sound elementary, and so they are, but they demand a deep change of attitude in anyone who has grown used to writing in the style now fashionable. One could keep all of them and still write bad English, but one could not write the kind of stuff that I quoted in those five specimens at the beginning of this article."

NOTE: In addition to "Politics and the English Language," also read "Why I Write", another of Orwell’s essays.


SOPHISMS (Fallacies):

A common mistake in presenting an argument is creating a sophism. A sophism is a fallacy which may at first seem plausible.

Example from "How To Win Every Argument", by Madsen Pirie (2006):
     "A US legislator recently noted that a high crime rate correlated with a high prison population, and suggested that the prisoners be released in order to cut the crime figures."

Example from "The Black Tulip", by Alexandre Dumas (Chap. 8):
     Mynheer Isaac Boxtel encouraged himself with the following sophism: --
     "Cornelius de Witt is a bad citizen, as he is charged with high treason, and arrested.
     "I, on the contrary, am a good citizen, as I am not charged with anything in the world, as I am as free as the air of heaven.
     "If, therefore, Cornelius de Witt is a bad citizen, -- of which there can be no doubt, as he is charged with high treason, and arrested, -- his accomplice, Cornelius van Baerle, is no less a bad citizen than himself.
     "And, as I am a good citizen, and as it is the duty of every good citizen to inform against the bad ones, it is my duty to inform against Cornelius van Baerle."

NOTE: I have heard legislators say that there should be a steep tax on tobacco because smokers have health problems that non-smokers end up paying for. In other words:
     All smokers have chronic health problems.
     All non-smokers have either no health problems or less-costly health problems.
     All non-smokers pay taxes.
     All treatments for smokers’ health problems are paid for with taxes paid by non-smokers.

You would have an impossible time sorting out the exact cost of health care for each and every ailment. Cancers, diabetes, and heart attacks correlate more closely to heredity than to diet or lifestyle. There are millions of non-smokers who have heart attacks just as there are millions of non-smokers who have cancer. Visit WVU Hospital and you will find infants and toddlers being treated for cancer or having open-heart surgery.

If you agree with the smoker vs. non-smoker argument above, then you might soon advocate a special tax on sugar (adult-onset diabetes), or a special tax on fatty or fattening foods (obesity), or a special tax on tanning beds, tanning lotion and any clothing that does not cover the entire body such as swimsuits (skin cancer).

Special whiskey taxes haven’t reduced alcoholism, DUI’s or DUI-related injuries and deaths. Indeed, the USA voted in the Prohibition Era, and we know how that turned out.

In the meantime, state legislatures across the nation have spent billions of dollars of tobacco settlement money (effectively, a steep tax paid by smokers) on everything but tobacco-related healthcare.


WRITING CONSIDERATIONS

Develop a historical perspective:
     Read and research your topic thoroughly lest you be caught up in the moment of popular sentiment.

(I)  Human-caused global warming is a popular issue right now. But did you know that Vikings landed at the tip of the Great Northern Peninsula of Newfoundland, Canada in the year 1000 and never saw the temperature drop low enough to cause a frost in the two years they remained there? Leif Ericson’s journals tell us that not only did Newfoundland have a mild climate, but that forage grass for livestock was plentiful year-round. Today, the site of Ericson’s settlement (approx. 2,000 mi. NE of Morgantown) is closed to tourists 8 months of the year because of the area’s harsh weather.

(II)  Thomas Jefferson is routinely criticized today because he was a slave owner. But did you know that Jefferson inoculated his slaves in 1800 with the first smallpox vaccine? Jefferson also sent the smallpox vaccine with the Lewis and Clark Expedition to inoculate Indian tribes. A century would pass before our nation began widespread smallpox vaccinations as a public health program-even though Jefferson contemplated the eradication of smallpox in his lifetime.


Develop your vocabulary:

It is important to develop a good vocabulary. It is equally important to tailor your words to fit your audience.

When I write a column for the State Journal, I keep in mind that 86% of State Journal readers have a college degree. When I write an article for the Appalachian Blacksmiths Association newsletter, I keep in mind that many of the readers aren’t college-educated and most of the ones that are have engineering degrees. Different audiences require different styles.

Each vocation and profession has its own specialized vocabulary as well as its own set of acronyms. It is imperative that you translate that specialized jargon into words that the everyday reader can understand.

And most importantly, always use active verbs that breathe life into your sentences.

Humor:

Not many writers can write humor. Some that think they can usually bomb. But good writers can and do use amusing anecdotes to lighten their criticisms.

There aren’t many writers like Dave Barry for a reason. But good writers can effectively borrow from pundits like Mark Twain or Will Rogers for a punch line. (E.g.: "Golf--a good walk spoiled." by Mark Twain)

Examples of use of humor from my columns:

     "Former Secretary of Agriculture Earl Butz (under Presidents Nixon and Ford) once addressed the Government Dependency Ratio this way. In the early 1970’s, it had become apparent that Social Security recipients would eclipse the number of workers paying into the system.
     "Mr. Butz compared the situation to his days growing up on an Indiana farm. He said he overslept one frigid morning and was late in going to the barnyard to feed the cows. When he got there, two heifers were suckling each other’s udder to stave off hunger. Then he added to his anecdote that, in such situations, some milk always ends up on the ground.
     "Mr. Butz, of course, was making a joke. Cows, unlike humans, are weaned from the teat." (Borrow It Forward, Jan. 19, 2007)

     "And now for the pièce de résistance-the Capitol cafeteria. This eatery gave new meaning to La Cuillère Grasse (The Greasy Spoon.) In fact, if the kitchen grease had caught fire, then the Capitol would have burned to the axles before fire crews got there! Fortunately, nervous cockroaches drew attention to the fire hazard which, in turn, prompted the health department to close the cafeteria. I am told that cockroaches are sensitive to fire hazards and need no special training to alert humans that danger is at hand.
     "Don’t laugh. The two prior state capitol buildings weren’t lousy with cockroaches and they each burned to the ground!" (For Government, Trailers Make Sense, Dec. 1, 2006)
 
Define your topic:

Writing an opinion column or editorial means you have limited space to convey your message. After you present your premise, you have to methodically and logically pursue your arguments to arrive at the conclusion. You have no grassy space to graze.

If you do go off point, you will most likely lose your reader.

One of the most common mistakes that writers make is "showing off." This happens when a writer has researched a topic at great length and then he proceeds to write paragraph after paragraph telling you about that research. Meanwhile, the reader is saying, "You’re telling me more than I need to know."

Be succinct and concise in your setup, premise, argument, and conclusion.

Be wary of bias:

Every writer writes with a bias. Men write like men, women write like women. Conservatism and liberalism are learned mainly from parents and upbringing. Geographical regions impart bias. A Louisiana Cajun’s idea of a good meal is much different than how Manhattanites dine in the Upper East Side.

Be aware of your own baggage before criticizing others.

If you were to write about a logging debate, you might quote the head of the local Sierra Club chapter for some background. That person will say that the trees shouldn’t be cut for any reason. At the least, balance the preservationists’ concerns with those of the logging industry. Their lobbyist will preen that "We are stewards of the forest and forests are renewable."

Reality is always somewhere in the middle of the debate.

In this instance, your readers will be amenable to pristine forests which provide habitat for not only Bambi but also for the endangered five-toed owl. At the same time, your readers also love to sit in front of the fireplace, solving the newspaper crossword with a #2 pencil while sipping Scotch whiskey that was aged in oak barrels.

Political bias is particularly daunting because of the desire to believe that Democrats are for the blue collar workers and Republicans are for the white collar professionals. In truth, Democrats and Republicans just want more spending money. They only differ in how they will get their hands on that money.

Actions, as well as inactions, have consequences, intended and unintended. Make your arguments based on how you view action or inaction. A good contemporary example of this is legislation raising the minimum wage.

Avoid promoting the agendas of competing lobbyists. Otherwise, there is no need for you to spend the ink. If you allow yourself to become a parrot, then you have failed as an opinion writer.

Statistics:

I majored in Economics and took two semesters of Statistics. I was also required to read How To Lie With Statistics by Darrell Huff, a clever primer that points out how people get selective when presenting numbers.

I strongly recommend that you read How To Lie With Statistics. It will demystify the numbers games. Another good book is Innumeracy: Mathematical Illiteracy and Its Consequences by John Allen Paulos.

Fact checking:

In Dragnet, the 1950’s television series, Sgt. Joe Friday always told the crime victim, "Just the facts, ma’am/sir." Crime victims are always hysterical and Joe Friday tried his best to sort out the facts during his investigation.

When George W. Bush was elected president, many opinion columnists wrote with near-hysteria that the number of homeless would increase by huge numbers. The facts have never supported this claim. But, many writers continued to make the claim based on subjective observations by the very people (or their trade associations) whose livelihoods depend on welfare programs for the homeless and destitute.


Think of facts this way. A policeman estimates the crowd that showed up for a public demonstration at 10,000. Without having a metered turnstile, we can never know the exact headcount. The policeman’s estimate is just that. However, such estimates are often reported as fact.

On the other hand, we know that precisely 68,918 fans attended the football game between the Univ. of Pittsburgh and Fordham University on Oct. 29, 1938. This was the turnstile number-a fact. Even so, Pitt’s publicity officer reported to the newspapers that 75,000 fans attended-a claim he later had to retract.

Today, it is common to actually misrepresent sports attendance numbers to the high side. When you hear terms such as "paid attendance" or "total attendance", know that neither number represents the actual turnstile number of fans who purchased a ticket for the game.

Facts are facts. And just as important, is the way that the facts are derived.

We know, for a fact, the exact number of voters who voted in the last election. Or do we? If you tracked down every registered voter who supposedly voted, you will find that some dead people still find a way to make their vote count. We also know that, in recounts, the recounted ballot totals are almost always different from the vote totals counted on Election Day.

And finally, remember that in our legal system, hard evidence and facts can be disallowed for various procedural reasons. This happens in both civil and criminal cases. Many cases also turn on the opinions offered by hired experts. When trying to understand our legal system, keep these two "facts" in mind as you try to make sense of the verdicts. We have a legal system that accepts opinion as fact and rules out fact by procedural technicality.


USING THE INTERNET:

The Internet is a great place to find erroneous information. You should rely on sources such as almanacs, dictionaries, encyclopedias, government agency reports, research papers that appear in peer-reviewed journals, and the like. (Primary sources)

I was schooled to avoid even periodicals (secondary sources) such as Time and Newsweek.

Also, familiarize yourself with several web search engines. There are many specialty search engines that deliver more consistent results than Google, Yahoo, etc.

Two websites for opinion columns that I read daily are: www.slate.com and www.realclearpolitics.com


Be wary of personal attacks:

The late Ned Chilton, publisher of the Charleston Gazette, once wrote an editorial about then-Gov. Arch Moore. He titled the piece, "The Sleaze Is Back!" Those four words told me that there was no reason to read further.

Harsh, shrill writing does not appeal to mainstream readers.

More importantly, if you have to revert to using words like "sleaze", then you have failed as a wordsmith.

There oughta be a law!

Editorial writers love to endorse the most recent act passed by the legislature. A year later, they end up writing an editorial pronouncing that the very same law either
     (a) went too far.
     (b) didn’t go far enough.
     (c) wasn’t supposed to do what it did., or
     (d) has actually made the problem worse!

Nine times out of ten, legislation is a combination of knee-jerk reactions and special interest favors. That is because the average legislator is not too bright of a thinker and owes his/her job to a special interest group.

A good example of this is the ongoing comedy of errors known as "ATV safety laws." In recent years, the WV legislature has passed law after law to regulate operation of ATV’s. Every year, editorial writers praise these new laws only to write a year later that the state has set a new record for ATV fatalities and that "new laws are needed."

Be careful what you wish for when you write: There oughta be a law. You’ll regret it.


Recommended Reading:

Goldberg, Bernard: Bias

Huff, Darrel: How to Lie with Statistics

Orwell, George: Why I Write and Politics and the English Language
Paulos, John Allen: Innumeracy: Mathematical Illiteracy and Its Consequences

There are two great satires that you should read: Gulliver’s Travels, by Jonathan Swift (1726), and Erewhon, by Samuel Butler (1872). In both instances, the authors wished to criticize their present-day. Doing so openly would have earned them the wrath of the English Crown. Thus, they created sophisticated novels to do the job. You will learn a great deal about using imagery (see Orwell at the beginning) as you read these books.

A best seller in Europe, England and the USA when published in 1944, The Road To Serfdom, by Nobel Economist Frederich A. Hayek, is an excellent economics book for the non-Economist. A condensed version appeared in Reader’s Digest, and Book-of-the-Month Club featured it. The Road To Serfdom explains the limits of government and the role of the marketplace in understandable prose.


Writing Exercise:

Examine a blackboard eraser and write a description of it (100-200 words).

Then, whittle away at what you wrote. Try to cut the word count by half without sacrificing any of the description.

Repeat Step 2.

The object of the lesson is for you to learn to polish your work.


After you are satisfied with the first part of the lesson, then use the blackboard eraser as a metaphor for Martin Hall in this exercise:

You have just learned that Martin Hall is too old to be remodeled for modern classroom facilities. The Journalism School will be moving to a new building next year. Classes will no longer be taught at Martin Hall.

Recall some of the words that your professor wrote with chalk and how the eraser removed them to make room for new words.

Make your reader believe that the words were forever imprinted on the eraser, not just erased and lost for all time.

Compare how you learned from the blackboard and speculate how you will learn from PowerPoint and video presentations. I.e.: Essentially an analog age vs. a digital age comparison. (Or, will the machine evolve into an intelligent being?)

Perhaps, you can make the reader understand that the words you saw on the blackboard were, in fact, never really erased-they were just transferred to your head. Then you can compare human memory and how we learn to the future when knowledge and memory will be stored in the machine.

Develop an anecdote about how class went on in Martin Hall when a thunderstorm knocked out the power one day. Express your thoughts about the future classroom and how it will function when the electricity is off.

Try at first to develop this essay in 500-700 words. In time, you might be able to turn it into a short story.



If you need inspiration, read: The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark; Act V., Scene 1, by Wm. Shakespeare. (Plus Cliff Notes and other references to the scene.)

(Excerpt:) Hamlet, holding Yorick’s skull in the graveyard:

Alas, poor Yorick! I knew him, Horatio: a fellow of infinite jest, of most excellent fancy: he hath borne me on his back a thousand times…

(Yorick was the court jester when Hamlet was a boy and, in this scene, he reminisces about his forgotten childhood friend.)

Friday, October 6, 2006

The Importance of Being Herb

Former WVU President E. Gordon Gee was recently featured on page one of the Wall Street Journal.  He now serves as Chancellor of Vanderbilt University, the fourth university which he has led since leaving Morgantown.  The list also includes the University of Colorado, The Ohio State University, and Brown University.

The WSJ article critiques Mr. Gee’s generous salary and perks.  And it also balances criticism of his compensation with praise for his outstanding fundraising ability.  Vanderbilt’s endowment has grown from $2 billion to $3.2 billion during Mr. Gee’s tenure.  That feat alone would make Commodore Vanderbilt proud of his namesake school.

Gordon Gee’s prominence is not new, however.  The national media discovered him while he was president of WVU.  Burger King ran a television ad campaign called "Where’s Herb?" Herb was promoted as the only American who had not eaten a BK Whopper and viewers were offered a cash reward if they spotted Herb in public.

As luck would have it, the actor who portrayed the fictional Herb was a dead ringer for Gordon Gee.  It wasn’t long before Mr. Gee was seeing strangers point at him and exclaim, "There’s Herb!"

"Herb" is again newsworthy just as David C. Hardesty has announced that he will step down as WVU’s President.  The university has formed a presidential search committee and I think it’s rather certain that the committee will receive two lists of candidates from which to pick.  So then, this is a good time to consider the candidates who hope to steward West Virginia’s flagship institution of higher learning.

First of all, the committee will hire a professional headhunter.  I always believed that headhunters and headhunting firms were nothing more than glorified realtors.  After all is said and done, they provide you with a handful of listings in your price range and then ask for their fee.  The headhunter’s list will be populated by professionals from academia-Herbs, if you will-and will contain most of the frontrunners for the job.

The second list, what I call the "out-of-work brothers-in-law slate", will be provided by state politicians and other power brokers who believe that patronage is the pathway to employment.  Patronage and nepotism have justified their existence, so pardon them if they know no better.

Sometime in March 2007, both lists of names will be commingled and the resumes will be thoroughly shuffled.  This is an important step in the selection process because it guarantees that some candidates will appear to be outstanding in comparison to others in their peer group.  The selection system then works as predicted, and is considered a success because most search committees never ask the all-important question, "As compared to whom?"

The search committee can avoid this trap by first identifying the needs of WVU before it even accepts a resume.  The job description drives the process, not the other way around.  Since the search committee is probably now defining the job description, let me offer my thoughts.

The next WVU president will face two major tasks.  First, faculty and staff salaries need to be raised significantly to insure that the university not only retains, but also attracts, the best personnel.  As WVU grows to 30,000 enrolled students, faculty and staff will also grow.  And second, the university’s growth and expansion needs to be financed by a method other than further burdening the already debt-laden student body.  Both of these goals can be mutually accomplished without compromise.

The candidate that WVU should be looking for can be best-described as the next Peter Ueberroth.  Ueberroth, you’ll recall, organized the 1984 Olympics in Los Angeles; the event made a profit of nearly $300 million.  He proved that a public enterprise could be of world-class quality without complaint while still being operated efficiently.

To the search committee, I say this: Forget List #1 and List #2. Go find the next Peter Ueberroth.  He’s out there, but his resume isn’t on file with academic headhunters and he’s surely not an out-of-work brother-in-law!

I have always said that David Hardesty is the best president that West Virginia University will ever have.  He was born for the job.  Even so, he had his detractors during the selection process.  Those who preferred List #1 said he lacked academic credentials.  Those who preferred List #2 said he would use the job as a springboard for politics.  Fortunately, the previous search committee ignored all of that claptrap.

Leading West Virginia University, the university where greatness is learned, is an honor and a privilege.  I wish the search committee well in its quest to find the candidate who is worthy of the title.

Friday, February 4, 2005

WVU Offers Lessons in "Cancer Stories"

The men and women you will meet in "Cancer Stories" are the bravest of the brave; they personify courage and integrity better than any model that I know.  Please cherish the moments that you spend with them for they and their families have made great personal sacrifices to bring you their stories.
   David G. Allen, "Cancer Stories"


If I sent you a one-hour video documentary about cancer, I doubt that you’d bother to watch it.

If I attached a note saying Ken Burns gave it his "Thumbs up!", then maybe you might.

If I pasted a flashy, "Emmy Winner!" sticker on the video, then maybe you’d put it in the "When I get time." pile.

What would you do, though, if I sent you a one-hour video and told you that it will help you answer the age-old question, "What is the meaning of life?"

The video and its companion book are "Cancer Stories: Lessons in Love, Loss and Hope."  Some of you have already seen it.  "Cancer Stories" premiered on WVPBS in December 2003 and has been re-broadcast.  The four stations owned by WV Media, which also owns the State Journal, also aired "Cancer Stories" (2004), uncut and commercial-free.

Most of you, and nearly all of America, are not aware of "Cancer Stories."  It is my intent here to change that.

Cancer remains the most dreaded diagnosis.  As soon as the doctor utters the word, the patient’s mind starts asking, "How long do I have?"  Not only does cancer instantly confront us with our mortality but it also makes us realize that the treatment will be a long and grueling ordeal.

I have long wanted to record the impact of the cancer diagnosis and the early days of the patient’s treatment.  Too often, we read only the testimonials written by cancer survivors.  We need these testimonials-for inspiration, and for science.  But testimonials do not tell the whole story.

As we age, we lose loved ones to cancer.  In subtle ways, we harden, or perhaps callous, our emotions to protect us from the next loss.  It’s perfectly natural that we react this way.  But it is precisely for this reason that older, experienced reporters cannot truly report the cancer story.  So it came into my mind that the ideal reporter for this story should be the young, curious, and unjaded, journalism student. 

I was appointed to the Advisory Board of the Mary Babb Randolph Cancer Center 2000.  From that vantage, I felt I had the standing to propose this project to West Virginia University President, David C. Hardesty, Jr.  The concept was simple enough.  Students from the Perley Isaac Reed School of Journalism would interview patients being treated at the MBRCC and WVU Press would publish their stories.

The "Cancer Project", as it was first called, was embraced across the WVU campus.  But it could not have happened without the support of eight wonderful cancer patients.  They are the men and women who have completely opened their lives to you and to the rest of the world.  They sacrificed their privacy so that you might have less of an ordeal when cancer comes knocking on your door.

When I say the patients sacrificed their privacy, I mean exactly that.  The student reporters were not only invited into the exam room but they were also invited into the patient’s home.  It is this unique, fly-on-the-wall perspective that allows you the audience  to share each cancer story as if you were a member of the family.

The doctors and medical staff at MBRCC are to be commended for the important roles they played in this project.  Before work began, the journalism students attended lectures on cancer, medical terminology, and treatment options.  Their extensive preparation allowed the students to be professionals on assignment.

You will, of course, see the doctors in their role as doctors.  But perhaps, for the first time, you will also see the emotional rollercoaster that cancer doctors also ride.

Thirty journalism students recorded "Cancer Stories" in print, photographs, and video.  The 220-page book comes with a DVD of the documentary.  In June 2004, the video documentary won the Midwestern Regional Emmy award in the Informational Programming category.  All of us who have worked on the project believe that the book will be heralded just as prominently.

West Virginia University has garnered high praise from its peers in academia and healthcare.  "Cancer Stories" is being considered nationally as a teaching medium for medical students.  And Journalism schools across the country are now considering similar "real life" reporting classes for their curricula.

To order your copy of "Cancer Stories", please visit www.wvupress.com or dial 1-866-WVUPRESS. [1-866-988-7737]